His Rumrunner Grandfather
[Mike/Editor] Reggie’s grandfather was gone before Reggie was old enough to understand his story, but the family legend lived on. For a young boy, it was a remarkable tale of dangerous seas, St. Pierre, smuggled liquor, big money, encounters with police, jail and, ultimately, an acquittal.
Looking back, I believe this history influenced how Reggie viewed his own involvement in the drug trade. His comparison between drug dealers and rum-runners was no coincidence. He grew up knowing that the grandfather whose name he carried had made money trading illicit liquor through many of the same waters and communities Reggie knew.
But family legends often romanticize the past. They preserve the adventure while overlooking the fear, danger, threat of imprisonment and consequences that might have followed. Decades later, Reggie made his own choices about risk, easy money and the law. His grandfather’s story did not determine those choices, but I believe it helped shape how Reggie understood them.
Reggie Alec? Who’s Alec?
“Alec” wasn’t his middle name. It identified which MacDonald family he belonged to.
Souris may be small, but there are plenty of MacDonalds. Traditionally, people with the same name were distinguished by tracing their family line through earlier generations. On our father’s side, my brother could be “Reggie Jim Reggie Alec,” while on our mother’s side, he could be “Reggie Helen Arty John Vitalis (V).”
For genealogists, this tradition is invaluable. A few words can trace a family back four or five generations. It’s a PEI thing.
The First Run — 1924
In 1924, my grandfather was a 23-year-old lobster fisherman with a lot of ambition.
Lobster was not the premium product it is today. A fisherman might earn only several hundred dollars in a year, there was no modern social safety net, and poverty was common. Families prepared carefully for winter, preserving food and storing root vegetables, salted cod and smoked fish. It was a hard way of life.
The previous fall, my grandfather had heard about a fisherman who made a “run” to the French islands of St. Pierre and Miquelon, bought a load of rum, brought it back to Prince Edward Island and more than quadrupled his money.
My grandfather decided he was willing to take the same risk. In December 1924, he set off for St. Pierre in his lobster boat. The boat had no cabin, leaving him exposed to the winter wind, waves and cold for much of the voyage. By the time he arrived, according to the family story, he was nearly dead from exposure.
While there, he met Henri Moraze, a major figure in the St. Pierre liquor trade. The two would eventually become close friends and do business together for almost 25 years.
The “Booze Scandal to End All Booze Scandals”
Rum-running also carried the risk of arrest. In 1935, my grandfather became caught up in a major Canadian liquor-smuggling prosecution involving more than 60 defendants. Among the best-known defendants were members of the Bronfman family, who had become prominent figures in Canada’s liquor industry.
The case was unusual because this was no longer primarily about supplying alcohol to Prohibition-era America. Prohibition in the United States had ended. Instead, Canadian authorities alleged that liquor exported tax-free to St. Pierre and Miquelon was being smuggled back into Canada, where it could be sold without Canadian duties having been paid.
A January 1935 newspaper account described the investigation as what the government believed was a “booze scandal to end all booze scandals.” My grandfather spent approximately two months in a Montreal jail before the case went to trial. He was ultimately acquitted.
The original newspaper pages are reproduced below. Because the surviving copies are difficult to read, enhanced versions have also been provided.
The Legacy Reggie Inherited
What Reggie inherited was not his grandfather’s trade, but a family history in which smuggling, risk-taking and encounters with the law had become part of the family folklore. The stories were passed down with the benefit of hindsight, their dangers softened by time.
I cannot know how much weight Reggie gave those stories when making his own decisions. But having grown up with the same family history, I can understand how the line between a colourful family legend and the realities of illegal activity might sometimes have seemed less clear than it should have.



